The game was a continuation of a campaign I think or a linked series of games, loosely involving the same characters if not players, this gives a kind of narrative to the players efforts and seems to be de rigueur these days with skirmish games, either this or a whole series of events triggered by dice rolls. Did I like it, it was fine, I can only compare it to Muskets and Tomahawks which I really enjoy. It is very easy to play, all of us picked up the mechanics within a turn or so, when shooting you have to score so many hits to kill, for instance if your target is in open ground every two hits kills one man, in cover every three. Like M&T shooting and combat can be brutal and deadly, shooting is to me strange, you can fire through woods, visibility seems to count for naught, there are no saves which I have gotten used to, five dead is five dead and hence this level of lethality tends to put your unit out of action very quickly. You also have to roll to activate each unit, a six with two D6 is required, it may not seem too hard but see below. One thing which struck me as strange is that line and militia infantry have a range of 18" while elites, like Grenadiers get 12", Stuart opined that this was to force players to use these elites in hand to hand combat rather than a firefight, nonetheless it seems daft to me. A very simple, quick game, with almost no learning curve and perfect perhaps for a club night, but without the bells and whistles of the 'campaign' and events perhaps too simple.
What about the game, well I was commanding two Provincial, one Light and one Highland (elite) battalions these were all twelve men strong. The figures used were as usual very nice and a pleasure to play with and observe. Simon had a motley crew on my right with some regulars and Indians along with six Rangers. We all had different objectives, mine was simply to clear the French from the area. No sooner had my men set off, well some of them, than the Jocks decided they did not like their officer of the moment and shot him in the back thus depriving me of his command incentive, this played havoc with my plan of advancing and shooting down Rob's Frenchies. I then fell foul of the range mechanic and my Highlanders began to be shot down without being able to reply, it would also be suicide to advance them so I was left with no alternative but to withdraw them.
Every player rolls a die at the start of the turn and the highest goes first, it then follows clockwise, although this was to my advantage initially I could not profit from it as turn after turn my units refused to do anything while all the time under a galling fire from the enemy. Simon meanwhile had disturbed a Grizzly with his Rangers and the beast killed most of the unit, he also ran into some quicksand later, Rob was set upon by a swarm of lethal wasps and lost a man to their stings. The events are not all bad and Simon got at least one extra unit. Meanwhile I began to lose units without inflicting any damage, I lost over half my force and the rest decided to go home. Although Simon had managed to remove Ian's men from the table he now had to contend with Rob's almost complete brigade, it was over.
I have a pile of bits and pieces primed and might start them today, I am in no particular hurry at the moment with anything having just finished another map project, I do have a toy cat to paint red today, long story. I admit it is warm but looking out the window it is damp, misty and grey, what a combination.
Your luck must surely change soon George!
ReplyDeleteI am now just hoping for average dice :)
DeleteGood luck tommorrow George, I hope CoC works out for you. It has a bit of a learning curve but 3-4 games is all that is needed. This QRS is absolutely essential to the game. Six pages but only need 4 if no vehicles. http://troubleatthemill.blogspot.com/p/chain-of-command-quick-reference-sheet.html
ReplyDeleteI got the QRS John, also sorted out markers etc. and have 'smoke' coming. Hope to get some good games in tomorrow.
DeleteOh dear I am in good company on the lack of success in battle front still. Better luck in your CoC games on Thursday perhaps.
ReplyDeleteThanks Phil, long day gaming, back to the keyboard for report.
DeleteAs you said the figures are nice, are they plastic?
ReplyDeleteActivation seems to be on every games agenda nowadays, I usually play individual skirmish games and activation is based on how good the character is, i.e. easier for a crack figure to activate than a duff one. I would expect a similar thing with units, a better one should be easier to drive along.
Tough luck with this game, it's most frustrating getting killed and not being able to retaliate, a bit unrealistic as well i would have thought:)
Some activation systems are good, many are bad. No big deal about the game, I am happy to play as we always have a good laugh. In the end my benchmark is will I play it again or not.
Delete